Report from Playtest Dublin #6

Since arriving in Ireland, I've missed tons of things about my life in Singapore - the food, the weather, the convenience, old friends - but one thing Dublin has given me is a community of game makers to interact with. Notably, the Playtest Dublin group has been a spot to bring my designs to more varieties of playtesters, and this has resulted in huge changes in my games, as well as development of my game design skills. Here's the report from January's large playtest sessions.

Sub Rosa: Spies for Hire

Sub Rosa: Spies for Hire is a bidding, bluffing, base-control microgame, which I've been developing since the middle of last year. I'll outline it's development in more detail in a later post, but for the sake of this article, playtesters were trying out a late version of the game. Sub Rosa: Spies for Hire has been through more iterations than any other of my games and has had a significantly faster development cycle - partly because it's a small game and partly because it's quick and easy to test. The playtests in January were all blind-playtests (I just gave the players the rules and left them to figure it out), and things went swimmingly. Players enjoyed their plays of the game and I've started locking down features for the final version. A print and play is imminent.

Sub Rosa: Spies for Hire

Watermelons

Another long-time design. This game started development in February, 2015, and there are quite a few posts on this blog outlining its development. At it's core, the game is a push-your-luck bluffing game, where players dare one another to take cards which may or may not be poisoned melons - if you get poisoned, you are out of the short round, but still score points, so it's a matter of deciding when it's most advantageous to meet your ugly demise. Since the last post here, the main changes have been with regards to the balance of healthy melons to poisoned melons, and the score values of those melons. Players really enjoyed this one and one group played the game, just for fun, an additional two times. Several groups of playtesters have told me that this game is finished, but I still feel like it lacks something. I think the next step will be to send it to wider groups of playtesters, to see how they respond.

Dropships

This is a quick dexterity game I put together the week before the playtest. I've been beating around the idea of making a micro-legacy game. That is, a game that changes each time you play it and comes with only a limited number of plays, but then also contained within very few components. Dropships is a war game where you launch ships onto a planet's surface to fight battles. Wherever these battles take place, the terrain is changed for all future games. The game itself didn't really work very well - the dexterity element of the game felt a little flat and uninspiring. I will probably return to the idea, after mulling over it for a while.

Space Traders

This is my Chinatown-esque trading game, about developing the best businesses on a space-mall. Players are free to trade any items they own - business licences, established businesses, renovation contracts, cash - and then they enter into a short, tile-laying phase, a little similar to Carcassonne, where there are certain rules about laying certain tiles. After this, players are paid based on how well they have developed their businesses and a new round begins. The game went fine, but it doesn't provide a unique enough experience to be interesting, at this point. I have some ideas regarding how to develop the tile-laying part of the game, to make things more interesting, but it'll have to wait until I have other projects out of the way.

Space Traders

Cliques

Cliques is a card game for 4-8 players which I've been developing for a while, with the intention to submit it to a game design contest. My intention was to have a game which plays a high number of players without having a lot of downtime, which typically happens with high-player-count games (Bang and Citadels being among the clearest examples of this). No changes came out of this most recent playtest of this and players had a lot of fun with it. This is possibly the game that I have playtested the most, at this point, because it's easy to pull out at normal gaming events. It's currently in the hands of the judges in one game design contest, and has been submitted to a bunch of publishers.

Modular City Game

I'm a huge fan of Carcasssonne and in December I picked up a set of micro-expansion for the game. These are 9 tile expansions that come in tiny boxes and each add a new mechanic to the Carcassonne base game. This got me thinking, would it be possible to design a game which consists of a set of standalone modules, which can be played separately or together? Every module could be made available for a low price, because they are small, but if you have enough, you could combine them to make a large and relatively unique game.

I thrashed out the idea for a while and decided that a city-building, tile-laying game could be interesting. So far I have made two modules - one is a small town module and one is a marina module. Each can be played alone, or if you combine them, you are playing a game about developing a small town by the sea. Players enjoyed the ideas presented in the game, but end-game scoring proved to be problematic. This is an issue with the tile-laying mechanic, rather than the modular concept. I'll continue to think this one through.